February 10, 2005

Quis Custodiet Ipsos Custodes?

El Reg just reported a major cross-platform flaw in 30 of Symantec's security products, including Norton AntiVirus 2004, corporate anti-virus apps and Brightmail spam filters. Of course the root cause is a system architecture which is so broken that it requires the use of antivirus software that is so tightly integrated that it becomes a potential source of compromise.

I've always thought that I understood the history - or at least the mythology - of how this came about. Cutler and crew knew (from their VMS days) how to make NT secure, but chip support, backward compatibility and performance "optimizations" did them in. They could have used Win31/DOS VMs to cope with the legacy crud, but it wouldn't have been fast enough. We're all living with the results today (even if we don't run Windows.)

I wonder how close this mythology is to reality....

Posted by geoff2 at February 10, 2005 11:04 AM
Comments
Post a comment









Remember personal info?



Anyone is welcome to leave a comment. However I reserve the right to delete blogspam,
as well as any comments that are abusive, irrational, or grossly off-topic.

Please copy the grey, four digit security code into the text box below.
This is to confirm that you are a human being and not a robot.